Home › How We Test
How we test
How We Test (and What We Haven’t Tested Yet)
Every sharpener on this site carries one of two labels. Hands-on tested means we’ve used it on real knives. Research-based pick means we haven’t yet, and we’ll show you exactly how we chose it. This page explains both, tells you where we are with testing, and how we earn.
We only say “we tested” when we’ve used a sharpener ourselves, on knives we name. Everything else is labeled research-based, built from makers’ specs, owner reports and how it suits each knife’s angle and steel. We earn through Amazon links, and that never changes what we recommend.
What our labels mean
| Hands-on tested | Research-based pick | |
|---|---|---|
| What it means | We’ve used this sharpener ourselves | We haven’t used it yet |
| What you’ll see on the page | The knives and steels we used it on, what happened, photos from our bench, and what went wrong | The specs we checked, where they came from, which knives it suits, and why we picked it |
| Where the facts come from | Our own use, plus the maker’s specs | The maker’s own pages first; retailer listings or owner reports only when labeled as such |
| Can it change? | Yes, if a longer test changes our view | Yes: when we buy and test it, the label changes and we say what changed |
We’d rather tell you we haven’t tested something than pretend we have.
Where we are with testing
Right now, every pick on the site is labeled Research-based pick. We haven’t finished a hands-on test we’re ready to publish, so we don’t claim one.
What we’re buying next: the sharpeners people ask about most, guided systems first, starting with the Work Sharp Precision Adjust and the Spyderco Sharpmaker. We’ll buy knives in different steels at the same time, so we can show how each steel sharpens on each system. As each test is done, the label on that product changes and the page gets a short “What changed” note.
How we test a sharpener hands-on
When we test a sharpener, we follow the same steps every time, so results can be compared across systems and steels. This is our method; results only appear on a page once we’ve actually run it.
| Step | What we do | What we record |
|---|---|---|
| 1. Set up | Unbox it, read the manual, set it up as the maker intends | What’s in the box vs sold separately; setup time; anything confusing |
| 2. Check the angle | Color the bevel with a marker and compare the system’s angle to the knife’s factory edge | Whether it matches the maker’s published angle |
| 3. Sharpen a dull knife | Start from a knife that won’t cut paper | Roughly how long to raise a burr along the whole edge; which grits we used |
| 4. Test the edge | Simple, repeatable checks: paper slicing, a ripe tomato, push-cuts | Pass or fail on each, in plain words. No invented “sharpness scores” |
| 5. Repeat on other steels | The same knife types in different steels (for example, a softer stainless and a hard super steel) | How the time and result change by steel. Almost nobody else records this |
| 6. Live with it | Use it for touch-ups over the following weeks | How easy it is to maintain an edge; what wears out |
| 7. Write it up | Short answer first, then the detail | What it does well, where it struggles, which knives it’s safe for and not for, and what we’d buy instead |
What we don’t do
- We don’t use lab equipment or a sharpness tester, so we don’t publish sharpness numbers. If that changes, we’ll explain the method here first.
- We don’t give star ratings. We’d rather tell you who a sharpener suits and who it doesn’t.
- We don’t reuse Amazon’s star ratings or reviews as our own.
How we choose a research-based pick
- 1
Start with the knife
Which knives and steels will people use it on? Which angles do their makers publish? (Find your knife’s angle)
- 2
Check the specs at the source
Angle range, abrasives, what’s in the box, from the maker’s own page. If we can only find a figure on a retailer’s page, we say so, or leave it out.
- 3
Match it to the knife
Can it reach the angle? Can its abrasives cut the steel? This is where we write the Safe for / Not for line.
- 4
Read the owners
Long-term owner reports and community discussion for common problems. We summarize themes; we never present them as our own experience or as testimonials.
- 5
Pick for who it suits
Every pick is “best for” someone, not “best ever”.
How we earn (and what that doesn’t change)
Art of Sharpening earns a small commission when you buy through our Amazon links, at no extra cost to you. As an Amazon Associate, Art of Sharpening earns from qualifying purchases.
- We don’t rank products by commission
- We recommend products people will enjoy, actually use, and keep for years
- We’ll tell you when you don’t need to buy anything at all
- We don’t accept payment for placement or reviews
Free products: we buy what we test ourselves. If we ever accept a product from a brand, we’ll say so on the review, and it won’t change the label or the verdict.
Sources, updates and corrections
- Sources: angle, grit and spec figures come from makers’ own published guidance. Where a figure comes from a retailer or an owner report, the page says so.
- Last updated: every guide and roundup shows when we last checked it.
- When we test a research-based pick: we update the page, switch the label, and add a short “What changed” note.
- Corrections: spotted something wrong? Tell us. We’ll fix it and note the change on the page.
What we don’t claim
We don’t hold a professional sharpening qualification, and we’re not a lab. We’re not chefs, and we don’t run a sharpening service. What we do have is a lot of reading, a clear method, and a rule we don’t break: if we haven’t tested it, we say so.
Find the right sharpener for your knives
Every pick is matched to the knives it’s safe for, and labeled honestly.
Questions about how we test? Send us a message →
